About Us

Helping Secure Your Future

Cotter Insurance provides quality insurance protection for individuals and families throughout Florida. Securing your future is our #1 priority.

By offering first rate coverage for your Home, Auto, Boat, Personal Watercraft, Trailer, as well as Flood and Umbrella insurance, we make sure that you and your family have the protection you need at rates you can afford. At Cotter Insurance, you have the benefit of working with insurance agents who have over 50 years of combined experience. We’ll evaluate your specific needs and find an insurance company that will give you the best value for your dollar.

Please contact us with any questions and get your free insurance quote today!

The Cotter Team

Christopher C. Cotter
Chris Cotter has been a licensed insurance agent for over 25 years in both Florida and Georgia. He began his career as a building inspector for State Farm Insurance and, after a tour in the US Navy, Chris continued his work in insurance sales and customer service. In April of 2009, Chris took over his father’s location and became an independent insurance agent. He is currently appointed by several property and casualty companies and has plans to grow his agency and stay in the Mandarin area of Jacksonville for the rest of his career.


Bill Cotter
Solicitor/Mentor/Customer Liaison
Bill Cotter has over forty years of experience in the insurance industry, including thirty eight years with State Farm. He was the original owner of the family business before retiring in 2009. Bill continues to be a part of Cotter Insurance by serving as a mentor and customer liaison.

Contact us today for a free quote. We’re here to help you!